SEC Football Blogger The Blog for SEC Football Fans!

Top Rated SEC Football Quarterbacks 1-12

06.09.2009 · Posted in Uncategorized

Top Rated SEC Football Quarterbacks 1-12. This article is a special feature made exclusively for our friends at SECFootballBlogger.  Please visit us at

From top to bottom, how do the quarterbacks of the SEC rank?  Do these rankings parlay into BCS success for their teams?  In most cases, the answer is obviously yes while in other cases, it doesn’t really matter.  This is an unbiased top-down analysis of each starting quarterback from the best league in the nation.

Upper Tier:

1.  This is a no brainer.  Unless you have been living underneath a rock for the past four years, Tim Tebowthen you know what Tim Tebow has done for the Florida Gators.  We believe that no explanation is needed.  Tebow simply accounted for 3500 total yards and 42 TD’s last season.  That’s all.  Even in an offense that lessened his physical hits, the man rushed for 792 yards + 12 TD’s….and then passed for 2,746 yards and 30 TD’s while only throwing 4 picks.  He has already won two BCS Titles, met Chuck Norris, witnessed to Death Row inmates, and cured cancer….twice.  Seriously, there are some major flaws that will limit Tebow’s success at the next level rather than this one.  He must improve his foot work in the pocket, make more concise pre-snap reads and work on his short to medium route throwing motion.  Other than that, win another BCS Title, feed the needy, and cure the Swine Flu.

2.  Jevan Snead:  Snead threw 29 more passes than Tebow, but only amassed 16 more yards passing.  He must improve his TD/INT ration (2-1) in order to lead Ole Miss over the hump into the fertile ground of the BCS Bowl system.  Snead has a fluid throwing motion, makes smart decisions (for the most part) and is a solid fit for Houston Nutt’s system.

3.  Jordan Jefferson:  Yes, we are either high on this kid or just simply high.  LSU had to burn his red shirt season due to injuries and Jefferson moved the team on up.  The kid reminds us of Ryan Perrilloux….minus the mouth and the police.  While only hitting on 49.3% of his passes, Jefferson had a 4-1 TD ratio.  Very smart player who should be able to push LSU past the pick six doldrums that were witnessed last season.

4.  Joe Cox:  Might not have Matt Stafford’s strong arm or smoking hot girlfriend, but Cox has the intangibles that coaches seek:  accuracy and leadership.  This was a risk putting him this high on the list due to only having 432 career passing yards…..BUT, Cox is not a newcomer and as long as he keeps his head screwed on straight without going Varsity Blues on the team, will have a successful coming out party.

5.  Greg McElroy: Another reach at this spot, but looking at the rest of the list, not THAT much of a reach.  McElroy made some good reads in the Spring Game vs a vanilla defense.  It will be interesting to see how he reacts to a chocolate chip defense with real live mean a$$ed SEC defensive linemen trying to extricate his head from his shoulders.  Did seem to get rattled from mistakes in the Spring.

6.  Ryan Mallet:  Was not THAT impressive at Michigan, but looking back at what he had to work with, maybe he did a better job than most think.  HUGE physical specimen, welcome to the SEC.  Will he be a product of  in a system the same way that Brian Brohm at Louisville?  Yes, but expect a TON of yards from that system.

7.  Stephen Garcia:  Otherwise known as Steve Spurrier’s heart attack in waiting.  Garcia has some untapped talent hiding beneath the surface.  If he simply settles down and plays within the system and learns to look before throwing the ball away, he will be ok.  Tends to force the ball too much and must also improve his ratio (6-8).

8.  Tyson Lee:  Can he handle Dan Mullen’s system?  In the past played well enough to keep the team from getting beat.  In the new system, MUST be able to make fast decisions and stick with the decision made.  How much of the actual system has been implemented?  When Croom took the job over, only 30% of his offense was installed prior to opening day…..on the day he was fired, apparently that number had fallen to less than 5%.

9.  Jonathan Crompton:  Has never reached his potential.  Former OC David Cutcliffe privately stated that Crompton would not have been his starter (if he had not taken the Duke job).  Must have an iron will and a strong backbone to withstand the beatings from SEC defennses and home town fans.

10.  Mike Hartline:  Lacks mobility.  Must improve his ratio (9-8) or he will be watching from the bench again.  Has the talent, has the QB coach, he just needs to settle down and take what is being given to him.

11.  Kodi Burns:  Did not have fantastic numbers last year, but then again had to learn a new offense in mid-season.  Will get better with experience.  Must anticipate where the safety is at and can not suffer through another 2-7 ratio year.  A simplified offense will make this player look like a stud.

12.  Larry Smith:  He has the generic name, plays for the team that doesn’t have an athletic department……the only reason we put Smith in this spot is simple:  he has only played in two games.  He slides to the 12 spot simply due to having less experience than the others.  Some will argue that several others have the same amount of experience, but it is really apples to oranges.  Smith has a bright future, but only time will tell.

Leave a Reply